New York Complementary & Alternative Veterinary Medical Association
  • Home
  • Contact
  • Join the NYCAVMA
  • Modalities
  • CONTINUING EDUCATION
    • 2027 EVENTS
    • 2026 EVENTS
    • 2025 EVENTS
    • 2024 EVENTS
    • 2023 EVENTS
    • 2022 EVENTS
    • 2021 EVENTS
    • 2019 EVENTS
    • 2018 EVENTS
    • 2017 EVENTS
    • 2016 EVENTS
    • 2015 EVENTS
    • OTHER EDUCATIONAL OPPORTUNITIES
  • Phil Rogers Archive
    • A >
      • Abstracts for Acupuncture in Gynaecology, Obstetrics, Andrology, Urology & Related Conditions - An Edited Bibliography
      • Achieving High Yield and High Digestibility With First-Cut Silage
      • Acupoint Codes, Names, Translations & Locations - Main Page
      • Acupoint Codes, Names, Translations & Locations - Sorted by Point Code
      • Acupoint Codes, Names, Translations & Locations - Sorted by Point Pinyin Name
      • Acupuncture & Traditional Chinese Medicine - Colleges, Societies & Discussion Groups
      • Acupuncture & Traditional Chinese Medicine - Supply Houses for Books, Materials & Software
      • Acupuncture Formulas - Top Ten Points for Common Conditions - Appendix 1
      • Acupuncture Formulas - Top Ten Points for Common Conditions - Appendix 2
      • Acupuncture Formulas - Top Ten Points for Common Conditions - Main Page
      • Acupuncture in Genitourinary & Related Conditions 1. Main Page & Contents
      • Acupuncture in Genitourinary & Related Conditions 2a. Summary of Points & Protocols - Overview
      • Acupuncture in Genitourinary & Related Conditions 2b. Summary of Points & Protocols for Female Disorders
      • Acupuncture in Genitourinary & Related Conditions 2c. Summary of Points & Protocols for Male Disorders
      • Acupuncture in Genitourinary & Related Conditions 2d. Summary of Points & Protocols for Urinary & General Disorders
      • Animal Frolics (1985-1991)
    • B >
      • Baled Silage - Development of Reliable Baled Silage Systems
      • Biochemical Variables and Trace Element Analyses for Animal Health Professionals
      • Bovine Fertility and Control of Herd Infertility
      • Bovine Mineral-Vitamin Balancers for Irish Maize Silage
      • Breakpoints to Assess Mineral, Nutritional Metabolite and Enzyme Status in Blood Samples From Cattle and Sheep at the Blood Laboratory in Grange Research Centre, CO Meath
    • C >
      • Calf Feeding and Management - Future Prospects
      • Calf Health and Immunity - Grange Workshop for Animal Health Professionals
      • Causes & Control of Bovine Ketosis
      • Chemical Composition of Common Wet and Dry Feedstuffs
      • Chemical Composition of Irish Forages - Grass, Silage & Hay
      • Complementary, Alternative & Holistic Approaches in Medicine & Veterinary Medicine
      • Control & Prevention of Copper (Cu) Poisoning in Sheep
      • Control & Prevention of Urinary Calculi in Lambs and Calves
      • Control of Calcium Imbalance, Hypocalcaemia & Milk Fever in Cows
      • Control of Mineral Imbalances in Cattle and Sheep A Reference Manual for Advisers and Vets
      • Copper, Iodine and Selenium Status in Irish Cattle
    • G >
      • Genesis Gone Wrong
      • Grange Research Centre, Blood Laboratory Page
      • Guidelines for Making Good Quality Baled Silage
    • H >
      • Herbal Ingredients - Sorted by Chinese (Mandarin) Name of Ingredient
      • Herbal Ingredients - Sorted by Common Name of Ingredient
      • Herbal Ingredients - Sorted by Latin (Botanical) Name of Ingredient
      • Herd Anaemia in Cattle
      • Herd Illthrift & Poor Performance (Growth, Milk Yield or Fertility) in Cattle
      • Herd Lameness & Laminitis in Cattle
      • Herd Mastitis & High Somatic Cell Count in Bovine Milk
      • Horses and Equine-Related Veterinary Resources
    • I >
      • Investigation and Control of Abortion, Perinatal & Early Postnatal Problems in Cows, Calves
      • Iodine Supplementation of Cattle - End of Project Report
      • Iodine Supplements for Livestock - Cattle, Sheep & Horses
      • It's Yerman Again
    • L >
      • Lamb Illthrift
      • Looking West
      • Low Level Laser Therapy (LLLT) - A Bibliography of Recent Papers
    • M >
      • Magnesium Supplements for Cows
      • Maximising Output of Beef Within Cost Efficient, Environmentally Compatible Forage Conservation Systems
      • Meta-Analysis to Assess the Efficacy of Phytotherapy - A Short Bibliography
      • Mineral Mixes for Cows & Other Cattle A Summary of Practical Options for Effective Mineral Supplementation of Dairy & Beef Herds
    • N >
      • No Man Comes From Nothing
    • O >
      • Outbreaks of Scour in Cattle & Sheep
    • P >
      • Phil Rogers' Offline (Hardcopy) Publications on Acupuncture, TCM & Holistic Medicine by Phil Rogers, Lucan, Dublin, Ireland for Students & Practitioners of Complementary Medicine in Humans & Animals
      • Pica, Urine Drinking & Depraved Appetite in Cattle
      • Publications on Aspects of Animal Health & Veterinary Medicine Authored or Co-Authored by Phil Rogers MRCVS
    • R >
      • Rough, Faded Hair Coats in Cattle
      • Routine Prevention of Mineral Deficiencies in Beef Herds
    • S >
      • Seed of Cain
      • Selenium Toxicity in Farm Animals - Treatment and Prevention
      • Silage Gas - Tabhair Aire - Beware!
    • T >
      • Teagasc Farm Nutrient Profile - Reference Information for Professionals
      • The Role of the Lab in the Investigation of Herd Health Problems Intelligent Use of Lab Diagnosis
      • This My Land
      • Travels in the Mind
      • Treatment of Prolapsed Uterus in Cattle (Vet Postgraduate Foundation, Sydney)
    • U >
      • Urea, Nitrate & Nitrite Poisoning in Cattle & Sheep - Sources, Toxic Doses, Treatment and Prevention
  • Medical Acupuncture Archive
    • A >
      • About "Acupuncture Qi", and What’s it All About?
      • Abstracts of the 5th International Baltic States Congress on Medical Acupuncture and Related Techniques
      • Abstracts of the ICMART '97 International Medical Acupuncture Symposium
      • Abstracts of the ICMART 98 International Congress on Medical Acupuncture and Related Techniques
      • Abstracts of ICMART 99 International Medical Acupuncture Symposium
      • Abstracts of Papers Given to the Brazilian Veterinary Acupuncture Congress
      • Acu-Point Injection in Gastric Ulcer and Diarrhoea in Foals
      • Acupuncture (AP) Treatment of Tinnitus
      • Acupuncture (AP) Treatment of Tinnitus A Bibliography from MEDLINE Abstracts (Aug 27, 1998)
      • Acupuncture: An Anti-Endogenous Opiate Mechanism?
      • Acupuncture Analgesia for Surgery in Animals
      • Acupuncture and Allied Methods in the Treatment of People with Cerebral Palsy: A Bibliography from MEDLINE Abstracts
      • Acupuncture and Atmospheric Electricity
      • Acupuncture and Homeostasis of Body Adaptive Systems - Acupuncture Bibliography
      • Acupuncture Effects on the Body's Defence Systems and Conditions Responsive to AP
      • Acupuncture for Immune-Mediated Disorders
      • Acupuncture in Cattle and Pigs
      • Acupuncture in Routine Veterinary Practice
      • Acupuncture in Small Animal Practice
      • Acupuncture in the Treatment of Herpes and Postherpetic Neuralgia: A Bibliography
      • Acupuncture, TENS and Electrostimulation in Phantom Pain: A Bibliography from MEDLINE Abstracts
      • Acupuncture to Induce Oestrus in Gilts
      • Acupuncture Treatments for Animal Reproductive Disorders
      • Acupuncture Treatment for Smoking Cessation, in 190 Cases
      • Acupuncture Treatment of Of Equine Sarcoid: Clinical Results
      • Acupuncture Treatment of Rectal Prolapse in a Mare: A Clinical Case
      • Advances and Instrumentation in Diagnosis and Treatment of Trigger Points in Human Myofascial Pain: Veterinary Implications
      • Adverse Reactions after Acupuncture: A Review
      • An Attempt to Treat Paratuberculosis Diarrhoea by Acupuncture
      • Anxiety and Acupuncture
      • Application of Laser Acupuncture in Children with Cerebral Palsy
    • B >
      • Ben Shen: The Five Psychical-Emotional Phases
      • Bio-Zoo-Acupuncture
      • A Brief History of Acupuncture and the Status of Veterinary AP Outside Mainland China
      • Bulimia Control - Treatment of Obesity and Weight Loss by Auricular Acupuncture in 800 Cases
    • C >
      • Case Study for Internal Medicine
      • Cellular Memory and ZangFu Theory
      • The Choice of Acupuncture Points for AP Therapy
      • Choice of Acupuncture Points for Particular Conditions
      • The Chongmai Link: Genitalia, Sexual Function, the Nose, Vomeronasal Organ and Pheromones
      • Classical Points Combinations and Clusters of Points, in Acupuncture Therapy
      • Clinical Acupuncture in Horses
      • Clinical Experiences with Acupuncture: Failures and Successes
      • Clinical Use of Low Level Laser Therapy
      • Common TCM Herbal Rx
      • A Comparison of the Influence of the Chinese and Western Philosophies on the Development of TCM and Western Medicine
      • Conducting a Double Blind Study of Acupuncture Therapy for Chronic Lameness in Horses
      • Continuing Medical Acupuncture Education A Brief History
      • Critical Comment on the Rogers and Skarda Review of Renzhong-GV26
      • Cultural Reference for Increased Understanding of the San Jiao
    • D >
      • Diseases of Cold Bi
      • Do Short Courses on Acupuncture - Pain Management Provoke Changes in Pain Patient Management?
    • E >
      • The Eight Strategies (Ba Fa) of TCM from the Aspect of Herbal Formulary
      • Electromagnetic Field Therapies: A Bibliography from Medline
      • Electromedicine - The Textbook of the American Academy of Pain Management
      • Emergency Acupoint Renzhong (Jenchung, GV26): A Bibliography and Review from Textbook Sources
      • The Epidemiology of Pain: An Australian Study
      • Equine Chronic Sacroiliac Subluxation: An Old Problem - A Novel Therapeutic Approach
      • Equine Headshaking: A Case Study
    • F >
      • Five Phase Theory and Its Use in Medicine
      • Functions of GV20 and GV21, from the ADA Database
    • G >
      • General Practitioners, Pain and Acupuncture: An Established Trend
      • Ginseng: A New Look at an Old Story
      • Girth Pain, a Common Cause of Suffering, Poor Behaviour and Occasional Reduced Performance in Saddle- and Harness- Horses
      • Gold Beads Implantation (GBI) – The Scientific Basis
      • Gold Bead Implantation (GBI) in Dogs - Good Medicine or Malpractice?
      • Gold Bead Implantation in Small Animals
    • H >
      • Herbal References by Energetics
      • Histological Observation of Canine Acupoints
      • Holistic Concepts of Health and Disease
      • The Holographic Paradigm and Acupuncture
      • Homeopuncture by Traumeel® Injection in the Management of Elbow Hygroma in a Dog: Case Report
      • Homeosiniatry in Modern Veterinary Practice
    • I >
      • Incidence of Adverse Effects During Acupuncture Therapy
      • Immunity: TianGui and Systemic Lupus Erythematosus
      • In Memorial of Dr Yiangos Karavis
      • Integration of Ancient and Modern Medicine Towards a Sustainable System of Animal Production and Medical Care
      • The Integration of Reflexotherapy and Transosseus Osteosynthesis: New Rehabilitation Possibilities at the Junction of Two Trends
      • Interim Clinical Results on Acupuncture in Cancer Treatment: Notes from my Casebook
      • Introduction into Systematics of Diagnosis and Therapy in Auriculomedicine as used in the German DAA/AM
      • Is Acupuncture an Electrical Phenomenon
    • K >
      • Kinetic Acupuncture (KA): Acupuncture Combined with Physiotherapy as a Systematic Treatment of 205 Cases of Musculoskeletal Disorders
    • M >
      • Mechanism of Acupuncture - Beyond Neurohumoral Theory
      • The Meridian System and the Mechanism of Acupuncture
      • Microacupuncture Systems as Fractals of the Human Body
      • Modern Neurophysiological Theories on the Effects of Acupuncture for the Treatment of Dental Pain
      • Myofascial Pain Syndromes: A Short Review
    • N >
      • Neuroscience, Neurophysiology and Acupuncture
      • A New Life of Contact Moxibustion
      • New Physical Interpretation of the Yin-Yang and Five Element Theory for Health Application (1):Constitution Classification
      • The New Reality of Acupuncture Medicine
    • O >
      • The Origins of Acupuncture Channel Imbalance in Pain of the Equine Hindlimb - A Revision
    • P >
      • Participant's Evaluation of MPE's Myofascial Pain Management 1997 Seminar
      • Point References by Energetics
      • Primary Evaluation of Homeopathic Remedies Injected via Acupuncture Points to Reduce Chronic High Somatic Cell Counts in Modern Dairy Farms
      • Prolotherapy in Animals
      • Psychic Methods of Diagnosis and Treatment in Acupuncture and Homeopathy
    • R >
      • Research on Biology of Acupuncture Has Met the Gold Standard of Science
      • A Review of Masanori Tanioka's Book "Wakariyasui Shonishin no Jissai" ("Easy-to-Understand Practical Pediatric Acupuncture")
    • S >
      • Sensory Stimulation with Acupuncture in Rheumatoid Arthritis: A Randomised, Controlled Study
      • Serious Complications of Acupuncture...Or Acupuncture Abuses?
      • Small Animal Cancer
      • Study Design in Acupuncture Research
      • The Study of Acupuncture: Points and Channels in Animals
      • The Study of Acupuncture: Sources and Study Techniques
      • Su-Jok Acupuncture in the Treatment of Bronchial Asthma
      • Sustainable Medicine for Veterinarians in the New Millennium
    • T >
      • The Taiwan Report
      • TCM Diagnosis and Treatment of Fibromyalgia Syndrome
      • Techniques of Stimulation of the Acupuncture Points
      • Temporo Mandibular Dysfunction and Acupuncture Energetics
      • Therapeutic Effects of Acupuncture in Calf Respiratory Disease
      • Traditional Chinese Medicine Principles in the Ethiopathogenesis and Treatment of Psoriasis Vulgaris
      • Traditional Versus Modern Acupuncture
      • Traditional Veterinary Chinese Medicine & Dermatology
      • Treatment of Backpain in the Horse and Dog by Acupuncture
      • The Treatment of Dental Phobia and Stress by Acupuncture
      • Treatment of Insulin-Dependent and Insulin-Independent Diabetes in Each Definite Clinical Case Using Wonderful Channels, 4 Energy Seas, Yin-Yang syndromes on the Base of Pulse Data and Pulsegram Analysis
      • Treatment of Low Back Pain with Specific Acupoint. A Double-Blind Placebo-Controlled Trial
      • Treatment of Post Herpetic Neuralgia with Acupuncture
      • Treatment of Skin Diseases with Acupuncture - A Review
    • U >
      • Understand Qi, Improve Your Practice
      • Unique Treatment Methods for Headaches
      • Use of Acupuncture and Allied Reflex-Therapies in Ulcerative Conditions: a Bibliography from Medline Abstracts
      • The Use of Acupuncture in Dentistry: A Systematic Review
      • The Use of Gui Pi Tang in TCM Internal Medicine
      • Using Western Scientific Methods to Prove the Efficacy of Traditional Healing Methods: A Proposal for a Large-Scale Human Clinical Trial
    • V >
      • Veterinary Acupuncture: A Bibliography from the Veterinary Library, University of Montreal
      • Veterinary Acupuncture is Reaching the Point Of Acceptance: Arising from TCM, This Age-Old Technique is Proving to Have Applications in Conjunction With Conventional Western Veterinary Practices
    • W >
      • Western Scientific Approach and Some Aspects of Tibet Pulse Diagnostics and Old China Acupuncture
  • FIND A VETERINARIAN
  • RESOURCES FOR PET OWNERS & VETERINARIANS
  • TIEKERT EDUCATIONAL SCHOLARSHIP
  • IN MEMORIAM - DR. IHOR BASKO
  • IN MEMORIAM - DR. CARVEL TIEKERT
  • NYCAVMA MEMBER WEBSITE
Picture

A Comparison of the Influence of the Chinese and Western Philosophies on the Development of TCM and Western Medicine

Attilio D' Alberto
Doctor of Chinese Medicine (Beijing, China), BSc (Hons) TCM MATCM
Introduction
Varies cultures throughout history have sought to construct life to understand the relationships between birth, death, sickness and health. When civilised cultures developed their skills and became specialised, healthcare physicians became a separated form within the community. Since then, they have sort to influence man's daily life. Chinese medicine has been notably more concerned with the nature of the cosmos in relationship to the human being, whilst the West preoccupied itself with the individual, their identity and the body's own cosmos. In Europe from the Greco-Roman times and in Asia, medicine changed its explanations of disease and healing from a transcendental basis to one in which the natural elements were governed within the law of the cosmos.

The aim of this essay is to explore the development of Western orthodox medicine and Chinese medicine with their accompanying philosophy. The comparisons of the two idealologies will also be discussed along with how these two philosophies might merge at a later date.

Discussion
Western medicine is greatly related to Greek thinking. Porter (1997, p7) states that Greek medicine emphasized the microcosm/macrocosm relationship between man and nature. Great attention was given to hygiene, which was seen as the root to all ills. This was carried forward later during the Renaissance period, where in actual fact no cures were ever found for man's great ills; i.e. the black plague, typhoid, tuberculosis, etc, rather it developed a preventative measure of medicine. Actually, the Renaissance period did more for knowledge than health for it was the basis of our modern understanding of Western medicine.

It was in the work of Galen that recorded dissections were first carried out but only on dogs and rarely. This was later carried on solely by European medicine in late medieval Italy. However, later during the Renaissance period, a flourish of anatomical and physiological studies began to emerge. These investigations were based upon the philosophy that all our answers could be found by delving deeper into the structure and flesh of humanity. It was Rene Descartes, the philosopher and physician who made a major contribution to Western medicine. He needed bodies to dissect, these bodies were controlled by the Christian church so he had to comprise with the Pope of Rome. The Pope agreed that he could have the bodies to dissect if he wouldn't have anything to do with the soul, mind or emotions, which were left to the church for exclusive control (Pert 1997, p18). This caused a major split between the body, emotions and the soul. Suddenly Western medicine had moved completely into the Greek notion of microcosm/macrocosm, but not within nature but just within the body itself.

It was not until the publication of Paduan's De humani corporis fabrica in 1543 that this theology was truly indoctrinated. It challenged Galen's teachings of anatomy with its own maps of the body drawn and studied during dissections. Later Harvey's De motu cordis, published in 1628 showed for the first time the workings of the heart in relation to blood. Medicine then began to sub-divide itself in scientific entities that we see today, notably physiological experimentation, pathology, microscopy, biochemistry and surgery. The advent of technology also helped to prove and encourage the growth of the microcosm/macrocosm relation held solely within the body. This was seen with the invention of the microscope during the nineteenth century. Medicine went truly inward as cell biology was born along with pathological anatomy. This lead to a greater understanding of the respiration system, digestive system and nutrition. It was largely Louis Pasteur and Robert Koch who established micro organic biology. Now medicine could look at infectious diseases like air pathogens, soil and water hygiene and person-to-person contact. Then within the twentieth century came the age of genetics and molecular biology.

During the West's industrial revolution, thinking began to be broken down into its sub units with Isaac Newton's philosophy of singular components. Suddenly everything was specialised and categorised according to its component properties. This advocated Western medical thinking. He believed that the body was a complex biological system in which abnormally functioning components could be removed and replaced with man made mechanical ones, i.e. the heart. After some time Albert Einsteinian's famous equation E=mc² came in being. It opened the way as Gerber (1988, p68) puts it for 'the conformation of the human being as a multidimensional organism made up of physical/cellular systems in dynamic interplay with complex regulatory energetic fields'. It thus confirmed acupuncture, Qi as the vital force of all things and the etheric body, although it has never been fully indoctrinated in Western orthodox medicine.
The modern mechanisms of thought was collaborated upon Renaissance thinking and Isaac Newton's theories by Charles Darwin. It reiterated the clinical view of man's evolution in their quest for survival and re-propagation of man's genes. This is contrary to one of harmony with man's environment as seen in ancient Greek and Chinese thinking to one of struggle, pain and death.

Since Western medicine moved away from its origins and developed its own philosophy on illness and disease it has created a personalisation of the physician. Chinese medicine however, is a collective weight of its tradition as a whole. Although individual Chinese doctors can translate and interpret traditional texts better than others based upon practical experience. This is why so much importance is given to practical application rather than theory.

Chinese theory was greatly politically orientated as we see with the shifting of views from Daoism to Confucianism to Buddhism to Communism. The Chinese empire became politically united in 221 BC. The Han dynasty established political, philosophical and religious teachings. It was built upon the four major classical texts, the Yellow Emperor's Classic of Medicine, the Divine Husbandman's Materia Medica, the Canon of Problems and the Treatise on Cold-Damage Disorders (Porter 1997, p149). One of the most important shifts in theory came from the transcendental texts of the I Ching. It was from there that the theories of Qi movement within nature derived from: the theory of Yin and Yang. This theory represents the duality of our universe: light and dark, high and low good and bad, etc, where Yin and Yang are in a constant state of dynamic balance. It is a philosophical concept in constant flux, therefore it is never fixed but in a state of continuous mutual consumption and support.

Daoism was based upon the teachings and writings of Laozi and Zhuangzi (c.339 – 295 BC). It stressed non-action (wu wei) by the need to withdraw from the world and following 'the way' or dao. Daoism is one of the oldest forms of Chinese philosophy. It has had popular support from society and the imperial state in which it co-existed alongside Confucianism throughout Chinese history. Confucianism was founded by Confucius (c.551 – 479 BC). It focused upon a series of key relationships and behaviour within social hierarchy. Confucius looked back to the 'Golden Days' of far-gone Emperors, where man lived in harmony with nature and others. His idea was to solve your own problems first then your family's and then your community's. Confucianism later brought in Daoist thinking to combat the sophisticated Buddhist teachings in an effect to maintain popularity. It became a corner stone of Chinese thinking and subsequent structures within Chinese state and society. Buddhism was introduced to China from the Indian subcontinent as early as the Han dynasty (200 BC – AD 220). It brought the ancient Sanskrit texts into China, which greatly influenced medicine and philosophy.

Chinese phonetics played a great part in all aspects of learning and life throughout history. Because Chinese characters remained the same throughout time, it helped to keep the important philosophical and medical knowledge that would otherwise have been lost. With that, the idea that spirits walked with the living also helped to maintain Chinese medical traditions, because of the need to uphold the ancestor's traditional ways.

There are many comparisons between Chinese philosophy and that of the ancient West. As Reid (1989, p80) reminds us, Hippocrates once said to his students 'Thy food shall be thy medicine'. This is identical to Chinese thinking: Sun Ssu-mo the physician wrote in Precious Recipes 'a truly good physician first finds out the cause of the illness, and having found that, he first tries to cure it by food. Only when food fails does he prescribe medication'.

Another example is Greek and Roman thinking: The influential Roman physician Claudius Galen devised a theory on breathing based on earlier Greek writers. He thought that a natural 'world spirit', seeped from the air down the windpipe into the lungs, along hollow pulmonary veins and into the heart, where it added special life to the vital flame. This vital spirit was then distributed throughout the arterial system (Parker 1993, p24). In Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM), air (Qing Qi) is mixed in the chest with the essence from food and fluids (Gu Qi) and then given the spark of life by the primary Qi (Yuan Qi) stored in the Kidneys to produce Zong Qi. This Zong Qi is dispersed around the body and to the Heart where it is transformed to produce the vital substance of all mammals, blood.

From Hippocrates to Galen humoral medicine was based upon the Greek's four elements; fire, water, air and earth, which in turn related to the four bodily fluids; blood, phlegm, yellow bile and black bile. In Chinese medicine, there are five elements or phases which are related to certain organs of the body.

Conclusion
There is a highly significant paradox to Western medicine: it is an unresolved dis-equilibrium between the powerful science-based medical establishment and the larger issue of unfulfilled health requirements of the people. Humanity today, lives in a wishful dream ideal of genetic molecular biology, when everywhere around us there is still disease, ignorance and unanswered questions, hundreds of years old, rotting in the corner where no one wants to look. Western medicine needs to change and update their philosophy from a Newton perspective to the more expanded Einsteinian view, even if this is difficult, if they ever want to restore their faith in the people who use it. This can only be lead by an evolutionary step in Western philosophy. We can only watch as Einsteinian's theory is full integrated into Western and Chinese medicine. From there, we shall see a more unified, whole and integrated philosophy and a new world healthcare system that is more effective at treating disease.

References
Gerber, R. (1988). Vibrational Medicine. Santa Fe: Bear & Company. 
Parker, S. (1993). Human Body. London: Dorling Kindersley. 
Pert, C. (1997). Molecules of Emotion. London: Simon & Schuster. 
Porter, R. (1997). The Greatest Benefit to Mankind-A Medical History of Humanity From Antiquity to the Present. London: Harper Collins. 
Reid, D. (1989). The Tao of Health, Sex and Longevity. London: Simon & Schuster.
Picture
All material © New York Complementary & Alternative Veterinary Medical Association 2026.
Website by Marble Hill Design
  • Home
  • Contact
  • Join the NYCAVMA
  • Modalities
  • CONTINUING EDUCATION
    • 2027 EVENTS
    • 2026 EVENTS
    • 2025 EVENTS
    • 2024 EVENTS
    • 2023 EVENTS
    • 2022 EVENTS
    • 2021 EVENTS
    • 2019 EVENTS
    • 2018 EVENTS
    • 2017 EVENTS
    • 2016 EVENTS
    • 2015 EVENTS
    • OTHER EDUCATIONAL OPPORTUNITIES
  • Phil Rogers Archive
    • A >
      • Abstracts for Acupuncture in Gynaecology, Obstetrics, Andrology, Urology & Related Conditions - An Edited Bibliography
      • Achieving High Yield and High Digestibility With First-Cut Silage
      • Acupoint Codes, Names, Translations & Locations - Main Page
      • Acupoint Codes, Names, Translations & Locations - Sorted by Point Code
      • Acupoint Codes, Names, Translations & Locations - Sorted by Point Pinyin Name
      • Acupuncture & Traditional Chinese Medicine - Colleges, Societies & Discussion Groups
      • Acupuncture & Traditional Chinese Medicine - Supply Houses for Books, Materials & Software
      • Acupuncture Formulas - Top Ten Points for Common Conditions - Appendix 1
      • Acupuncture Formulas - Top Ten Points for Common Conditions - Appendix 2
      • Acupuncture Formulas - Top Ten Points for Common Conditions - Main Page
      • Acupuncture in Genitourinary & Related Conditions 1. Main Page & Contents
      • Acupuncture in Genitourinary & Related Conditions 2a. Summary of Points & Protocols - Overview
      • Acupuncture in Genitourinary & Related Conditions 2b. Summary of Points & Protocols for Female Disorders
      • Acupuncture in Genitourinary & Related Conditions 2c. Summary of Points & Protocols for Male Disorders
      • Acupuncture in Genitourinary & Related Conditions 2d. Summary of Points & Protocols for Urinary & General Disorders
      • Animal Frolics (1985-1991)
    • B >
      • Baled Silage - Development of Reliable Baled Silage Systems
      • Biochemical Variables and Trace Element Analyses for Animal Health Professionals
      • Bovine Fertility and Control of Herd Infertility
      • Bovine Mineral-Vitamin Balancers for Irish Maize Silage
      • Breakpoints to Assess Mineral, Nutritional Metabolite and Enzyme Status in Blood Samples From Cattle and Sheep at the Blood Laboratory in Grange Research Centre, CO Meath
    • C >
      • Calf Feeding and Management - Future Prospects
      • Calf Health and Immunity - Grange Workshop for Animal Health Professionals
      • Causes & Control of Bovine Ketosis
      • Chemical Composition of Common Wet and Dry Feedstuffs
      • Chemical Composition of Irish Forages - Grass, Silage & Hay
      • Complementary, Alternative & Holistic Approaches in Medicine & Veterinary Medicine
      • Control & Prevention of Copper (Cu) Poisoning in Sheep
      • Control & Prevention of Urinary Calculi in Lambs and Calves
      • Control of Calcium Imbalance, Hypocalcaemia & Milk Fever in Cows
      • Control of Mineral Imbalances in Cattle and Sheep A Reference Manual for Advisers and Vets
      • Copper, Iodine and Selenium Status in Irish Cattle
    • G >
      • Genesis Gone Wrong
      • Grange Research Centre, Blood Laboratory Page
      • Guidelines for Making Good Quality Baled Silage
    • H >
      • Herbal Ingredients - Sorted by Chinese (Mandarin) Name of Ingredient
      • Herbal Ingredients - Sorted by Common Name of Ingredient
      • Herbal Ingredients - Sorted by Latin (Botanical) Name of Ingredient
      • Herd Anaemia in Cattle
      • Herd Illthrift & Poor Performance (Growth, Milk Yield or Fertility) in Cattle
      • Herd Lameness & Laminitis in Cattle
      • Herd Mastitis & High Somatic Cell Count in Bovine Milk
      • Horses and Equine-Related Veterinary Resources
    • I >
      • Investigation and Control of Abortion, Perinatal & Early Postnatal Problems in Cows, Calves
      • Iodine Supplementation of Cattle - End of Project Report
      • Iodine Supplements for Livestock - Cattle, Sheep & Horses
      • It's Yerman Again
    • L >
      • Lamb Illthrift
      • Looking West
      • Low Level Laser Therapy (LLLT) - A Bibliography of Recent Papers
    • M >
      • Magnesium Supplements for Cows
      • Maximising Output of Beef Within Cost Efficient, Environmentally Compatible Forage Conservation Systems
      • Meta-Analysis to Assess the Efficacy of Phytotherapy - A Short Bibliography
      • Mineral Mixes for Cows & Other Cattle A Summary of Practical Options for Effective Mineral Supplementation of Dairy & Beef Herds
    • N >
      • No Man Comes From Nothing
    • O >
      • Outbreaks of Scour in Cattle & Sheep
    • P >
      • Phil Rogers' Offline (Hardcopy) Publications on Acupuncture, TCM & Holistic Medicine by Phil Rogers, Lucan, Dublin, Ireland for Students & Practitioners of Complementary Medicine in Humans & Animals
      • Pica, Urine Drinking & Depraved Appetite in Cattle
      • Publications on Aspects of Animal Health & Veterinary Medicine Authored or Co-Authored by Phil Rogers MRCVS
    • R >
      • Rough, Faded Hair Coats in Cattle
      • Routine Prevention of Mineral Deficiencies in Beef Herds
    • S >
      • Seed of Cain
      • Selenium Toxicity in Farm Animals - Treatment and Prevention
      • Silage Gas - Tabhair Aire - Beware!
    • T >
      • Teagasc Farm Nutrient Profile - Reference Information for Professionals
      • The Role of the Lab in the Investigation of Herd Health Problems Intelligent Use of Lab Diagnosis
      • This My Land
      • Travels in the Mind
      • Treatment of Prolapsed Uterus in Cattle (Vet Postgraduate Foundation, Sydney)
    • U >
      • Urea, Nitrate & Nitrite Poisoning in Cattle & Sheep - Sources, Toxic Doses, Treatment and Prevention
  • Medical Acupuncture Archive
    • A >
      • About "Acupuncture Qi", and What’s it All About?
      • Abstracts of the 5th International Baltic States Congress on Medical Acupuncture and Related Techniques
      • Abstracts of the ICMART '97 International Medical Acupuncture Symposium
      • Abstracts of the ICMART 98 International Congress on Medical Acupuncture and Related Techniques
      • Abstracts of ICMART 99 International Medical Acupuncture Symposium
      • Abstracts of Papers Given to the Brazilian Veterinary Acupuncture Congress
      • Acu-Point Injection in Gastric Ulcer and Diarrhoea in Foals
      • Acupuncture (AP) Treatment of Tinnitus
      • Acupuncture (AP) Treatment of Tinnitus A Bibliography from MEDLINE Abstracts (Aug 27, 1998)
      • Acupuncture: An Anti-Endogenous Opiate Mechanism?
      • Acupuncture Analgesia for Surgery in Animals
      • Acupuncture and Allied Methods in the Treatment of People with Cerebral Palsy: A Bibliography from MEDLINE Abstracts
      • Acupuncture and Atmospheric Electricity
      • Acupuncture and Homeostasis of Body Adaptive Systems - Acupuncture Bibliography
      • Acupuncture Effects on the Body's Defence Systems and Conditions Responsive to AP
      • Acupuncture for Immune-Mediated Disorders
      • Acupuncture in Cattle and Pigs
      • Acupuncture in Routine Veterinary Practice
      • Acupuncture in Small Animal Practice
      • Acupuncture in the Treatment of Herpes and Postherpetic Neuralgia: A Bibliography
      • Acupuncture, TENS and Electrostimulation in Phantom Pain: A Bibliography from MEDLINE Abstracts
      • Acupuncture to Induce Oestrus in Gilts
      • Acupuncture Treatments for Animal Reproductive Disorders
      • Acupuncture Treatment for Smoking Cessation, in 190 Cases
      • Acupuncture Treatment of Of Equine Sarcoid: Clinical Results
      • Acupuncture Treatment of Rectal Prolapse in a Mare: A Clinical Case
      • Advances and Instrumentation in Diagnosis and Treatment of Trigger Points in Human Myofascial Pain: Veterinary Implications
      • Adverse Reactions after Acupuncture: A Review
      • An Attempt to Treat Paratuberculosis Diarrhoea by Acupuncture
      • Anxiety and Acupuncture
      • Application of Laser Acupuncture in Children with Cerebral Palsy
    • B >
      • Ben Shen: The Five Psychical-Emotional Phases
      • Bio-Zoo-Acupuncture
      • A Brief History of Acupuncture and the Status of Veterinary AP Outside Mainland China
      • Bulimia Control - Treatment of Obesity and Weight Loss by Auricular Acupuncture in 800 Cases
    • C >
      • Case Study for Internal Medicine
      • Cellular Memory and ZangFu Theory
      • The Choice of Acupuncture Points for AP Therapy
      • Choice of Acupuncture Points for Particular Conditions
      • The Chongmai Link: Genitalia, Sexual Function, the Nose, Vomeronasal Organ and Pheromones
      • Classical Points Combinations and Clusters of Points, in Acupuncture Therapy
      • Clinical Acupuncture in Horses
      • Clinical Experiences with Acupuncture: Failures and Successes
      • Clinical Use of Low Level Laser Therapy
      • Common TCM Herbal Rx
      • A Comparison of the Influence of the Chinese and Western Philosophies on the Development of TCM and Western Medicine
      • Conducting a Double Blind Study of Acupuncture Therapy for Chronic Lameness in Horses
      • Continuing Medical Acupuncture Education A Brief History
      • Critical Comment on the Rogers and Skarda Review of Renzhong-GV26
      • Cultural Reference for Increased Understanding of the San Jiao
    • D >
      • Diseases of Cold Bi
      • Do Short Courses on Acupuncture - Pain Management Provoke Changes in Pain Patient Management?
    • E >
      • The Eight Strategies (Ba Fa) of TCM from the Aspect of Herbal Formulary
      • Electromagnetic Field Therapies: A Bibliography from Medline
      • Electromedicine - The Textbook of the American Academy of Pain Management
      • Emergency Acupoint Renzhong (Jenchung, GV26): A Bibliography and Review from Textbook Sources
      • The Epidemiology of Pain: An Australian Study
      • Equine Chronic Sacroiliac Subluxation: An Old Problem - A Novel Therapeutic Approach
      • Equine Headshaking: A Case Study
    • F >
      • Five Phase Theory and Its Use in Medicine
      • Functions of GV20 and GV21, from the ADA Database
    • G >
      • General Practitioners, Pain and Acupuncture: An Established Trend
      • Ginseng: A New Look at an Old Story
      • Girth Pain, a Common Cause of Suffering, Poor Behaviour and Occasional Reduced Performance in Saddle- and Harness- Horses
      • Gold Beads Implantation (GBI) – The Scientific Basis
      • Gold Bead Implantation (GBI) in Dogs - Good Medicine or Malpractice?
      • Gold Bead Implantation in Small Animals
    • H >
      • Herbal References by Energetics
      • Histological Observation of Canine Acupoints
      • Holistic Concepts of Health and Disease
      • The Holographic Paradigm and Acupuncture
      • Homeopuncture by Traumeel® Injection in the Management of Elbow Hygroma in a Dog: Case Report
      • Homeosiniatry in Modern Veterinary Practice
    • I >
      • Incidence of Adverse Effects During Acupuncture Therapy
      • Immunity: TianGui and Systemic Lupus Erythematosus
      • In Memorial of Dr Yiangos Karavis
      • Integration of Ancient and Modern Medicine Towards a Sustainable System of Animal Production and Medical Care
      • The Integration of Reflexotherapy and Transosseus Osteosynthesis: New Rehabilitation Possibilities at the Junction of Two Trends
      • Interim Clinical Results on Acupuncture in Cancer Treatment: Notes from my Casebook
      • Introduction into Systematics of Diagnosis and Therapy in Auriculomedicine as used in the German DAA/AM
      • Is Acupuncture an Electrical Phenomenon
    • K >
      • Kinetic Acupuncture (KA): Acupuncture Combined with Physiotherapy as a Systematic Treatment of 205 Cases of Musculoskeletal Disorders
    • M >
      • Mechanism of Acupuncture - Beyond Neurohumoral Theory
      • The Meridian System and the Mechanism of Acupuncture
      • Microacupuncture Systems as Fractals of the Human Body
      • Modern Neurophysiological Theories on the Effects of Acupuncture for the Treatment of Dental Pain
      • Myofascial Pain Syndromes: A Short Review
    • N >
      • Neuroscience, Neurophysiology and Acupuncture
      • A New Life of Contact Moxibustion
      • New Physical Interpretation of the Yin-Yang and Five Element Theory for Health Application (1):Constitution Classification
      • The New Reality of Acupuncture Medicine
    • O >
      • The Origins of Acupuncture Channel Imbalance in Pain of the Equine Hindlimb - A Revision
    • P >
      • Participant's Evaluation of MPE's Myofascial Pain Management 1997 Seminar
      • Point References by Energetics
      • Primary Evaluation of Homeopathic Remedies Injected via Acupuncture Points to Reduce Chronic High Somatic Cell Counts in Modern Dairy Farms
      • Prolotherapy in Animals
      • Psychic Methods of Diagnosis and Treatment in Acupuncture and Homeopathy
    • R >
      • Research on Biology of Acupuncture Has Met the Gold Standard of Science
      • A Review of Masanori Tanioka's Book "Wakariyasui Shonishin no Jissai" ("Easy-to-Understand Practical Pediatric Acupuncture")
    • S >
      • Sensory Stimulation with Acupuncture in Rheumatoid Arthritis: A Randomised, Controlled Study
      • Serious Complications of Acupuncture...Or Acupuncture Abuses?
      • Small Animal Cancer
      • Study Design in Acupuncture Research
      • The Study of Acupuncture: Points and Channels in Animals
      • The Study of Acupuncture: Sources and Study Techniques
      • Su-Jok Acupuncture in the Treatment of Bronchial Asthma
      • Sustainable Medicine for Veterinarians in the New Millennium
    • T >
      • The Taiwan Report
      • TCM Diagnosis and Treatment of Fibromyalgia Syndrome
      • Techniques of Stimulation of the Acupuncture Points
      • Temporo Mandibular Dysfunction and Acupuncture Energetics
      • Therapeutic Effects of Acupuncture in Calf Respiratory Disease
      • Traditional Chinese Medicine Principles in the Ethiopathogenesis and Treatment of Psoriasis Vulgaris
      • Traditional Versus Modern Acupuncture
      • Traditional Veterinary Chinese Medicine & Dermatology
      • Treatment of Backpain in the Horse and Dog by Acupuncture
      • The Treatment of Dental Phobia and Stress by Acupuncture
      • Treatment of Insulin-Dependent and Insulin-Independent Diabetes in Each Definite Clinical Case Using Wonderful Channels, 4 Energy Seas, Yin-Yang syndromes on the Base of Pulse Data and Pulsegram Analysis
      • Treatment of Low Back Pain with Specific Acupoint. A Double-Blind Placebo-Controlled Trial
      • Treatment of Post Herpetic Neuralgia with Acupuncture
      • Treatment of Skin Diseases with Acupuncture - A Review
    • U >
      • Understand Qi, Improve Your Practice
      • Unique Treatment Methods for Headaches
      • Use of Acupuncture and Allied Reflex-Therapies in Ulcerative Conditions: a Bibliography from Medline Abstracts
      • The Use of Acupuncture in Dentistry: A Systematic Review
      • The Use of Gui Pi Tang in TCM Internal Medicine
      • Using Western Scientific Methods to Prove the Efficacy of Traditional Healing Methods: A Proposal for a Large-Scale Human Clinical Trial
    • V >
      • Veterinary Acupuncture: A Bibliography from the Veterinary Library, University of Montreal
      • Veterinary Acupuncture is Reaching the Point Of Acceptance: Arising from TCM, This Age-Old Technique is Proving to Have Applications in Conjunction With Conventional Western Veterinary Practices
    • W >
      • Western Scientific Approach and Some Aspects of Tibet Pulse Diagnostics and Old China Acupuncture
  • FIND A VETERINARIAN
  • RESOURCES FOR PET OWNERS & VETERINARIANS
  • TIEKERT EDUCATIONAL SCHOLARSHIP
  • IN MEMORIAM - DR. IHOR BASKO
  • IN MEMORIAM - DR. CARVEL TIEKERT
  • NYCAVMA MEMBER WEBSITE